Diamond vs Sapphire Engagement Rings

Diamond vs Sapphire Engagement Rings

Wedding and engagement rings are perhaps the most important pieces of jewellery you can ever purchase. One of the biggest components of choosing the perfect ring is the gemstone used in its design.

When it comes to choosing the perfect engagement ring, the decision between a diamond and a sapphire can be a tough one. Both gemstones have their own unique qualities and appeal, so it's important to understand the pros and cons of each before making your final choice. We are so spoiled for choice when it comes to custom jewellery in Australia, so we've broken down the basics of what you should know about diamond vs sapphire engagement rings...

A brief history of diamond engagement rings

Diamonds have long been a symbol of love and commitment, making them the perfect choice for engagement rings. But how did diamonds become so closely associated with this tradition? Let's delve into the fascinating history of diamonds in engagement rings.

The tradition of giving diamond engagement rings dates back to the 15th century, however, it wasn't until the late 19th century that diamonds became more widely available and affordable.

One factor leading to diamonds long lasting popularity in engagement rings is the fact that diamonds are the hardest natural substance on Earth, making them a symbol of enduring love and strength. Their brilliance and sparkle also make them a visually stunning choice for engagement rings. Additionally, diamonds are rare, adding to their allure and value.

While traditional solitaire diamond engagement rings remain popular, there are now a variety of styles and settings to choose from, including halo, three-stone, and vintage-inspired designs. Lab-created diamonds have also become a more sustainable and affordable option for modern couples.

But what about sapphire engagement rings?

When it comes to engagement rings, diamonds may be the traditional choice, but sapphires are gaining popularity for their stunning beauty and unique appeal. Sapphires are a variety of the mineral corundum, known for their rich blue colour. However, sapphires can come in a range of colours, including pink, yellow, green and every colour in between. Their durability and brilliance make them an excellent choice for everyday wear, perfect for symbolising a lasting commitment in an engagement ring.

They have a long history of being used in jewellery, dating back to ancient civilizations. Royalty often adorned themselves with sapphires, associating the gemstone with virtue, and good fortune.

It wasn't until the 1980s that sapphires started to gain popularity in engagement rings, thanks to Princess Diana's iconic sapphire and diamond engagement ring. Since then, sapphires have become a symbol of elegance and individuality in the world of engagement rings.

Aside from their stunning beauty, sapphires offer a unique and meaningful alternative to traditional diamond engagement rings. Sapphires are said to symbolise loyalty, trust, and faithfulness, making them a perfect choice for couples looking to express their deep connection and commitment.

What are the key differences between diamond and sapphire engagement rings?

Diamonds are known for their brilliance and sparkle, making them a popular choice for engagement rings. They are the hardest natural substance on Earth, scoring a perfect 10 on the Mohs scale of mineral hardness. This makes diamonds extremely durable and resistant to scratches, perfect for everyday wear.

On the other hand, sapphires are a type of corundum mineral that come in a variety of colours, with blue being the most traditional choice for engagement rings. While not as hard as diam ononds, sapphires still rank high the Mohs scale with a score of 9, making them a durable option for everyday wear.


More on diamonds in engagement rings

Diamond engagement rings have long been a symbol of love and commitment. But before you make the decision to purchase one, it's important to consider the pros and cons.

What are the pros of choosing a diamond engagement ring?

1. Timeless: Diamonds are known for their timeless beauty and elegance. They never go out of style and can be passed down for generations.

2. Renowned clarity: Diamonds have a clear colour that not only catches the light in a myriad of ways but also matches everything, making them a versatile choice for any outfit or occasion.

3. Variety of colours: While diamonds are typically clear, they also come in a variety of soft colours such as pink, yellow, and blue, offering a unique touch to your ring.

What are the cons of choosing a diamond engagement ring?

1. Common: Diamond engagement rings are a popular choice, which means that many people have them. If you're looking for something more unique, a diamond ring may not be the best option.

2. Expensive: Diamonds are known for their high price tag, especially when choosing a natural diamond (as opposed to lab-grown). If budget is a concern, you may want to explore alternative options that offer a similar look without the hefty cost.


More on sapphires in engagement rings

When it comes to choosing an engagement ring, the options can seem endless. One unique choice that has been gaining popularity is the sapphire engagement ring. But what are the pros and cons of opting for this stunning gemstone over the traditional diamond?

What are the pros of choosing a sapphire engagement ring?

1. Range of Vibrant Colors: One of the biggest advantages of sapphire engagement rings is the wide array of colors available. From deep blues to vibrant pinks, sapphires offer a unique and personalized look for the wearer.

2. Uniqueness: While diamonds are a classic choice for engagement rings, sapphires offer more individualised options. Sapphire rings can show thoughtfulness and creativity in selecting a ring that truly reflects the recipient's personality.

3. Similar Shine and Cuts: Sapphires are known for their brilliance and sparkle, making them a close rival to diamonds in terms of shine. Additionally, sapphires can be cut in various styles, allowing for a customized and eye-catching ring.

4. Affordability: Compared to diamonds, sapphires are generally more affordable. This can be a significant advantage for couples looking to save money without compromising on beauty and quality.

What are the cons of choosing a sapphire engagement ring?

1. Lack of Tradition: While sapphire engagement rings are becoming more popular, they still lack the traditional status of diamond rings. Some may prefer to stick with the time-honored choice of a diamond for their engagement ring.

2. Prestige: Diamonds have long been associated with luxury and prestige, making them a symbol of commitment and status. Choosing a sapphire ring may not carry the same level of prestige as a diamond ring.


Ultimately, the decision between a sapphire and diamond engagement ring comes down to personal preference and what holds significance for the couple. While sapphires offer a unique and colourful alternative to diamonds, some may prefer the timeless elegance and prestige of a diamond. Whichever choice is made, the most important factor is that the ring symbolises the love and commitment shared between two individuals. Having your dream ring with either sapphire or diamond custom made just for you is another way to instantly elevate any design.

Back to blog